Useful working document for a rigorous disciplinary procedure
The disciplinary investigation report is frequently used to synthesize the facts, evidence, defenses of the employee, and the conclusions of the authorized person. The labor code does not impose a standard form for the report, but it requires a prior disciplinary investigation in most situations and strict conditions for the sanctioning decision.
What the labor code says
Except for a written warning, no disciplinary sanction can be imposed before conducting the prior disciplinary investigation. The employee must be summoned in writing, indicating the subject, date, time, and place of the meeting.
During the investigation, the employee has the right to formulate their defenses, propose evidence and motivations, and, upon request, to be assisted by a lawyer or by the representative of the union of which they are a member. Failure to appear without objective reason at the legal summons allows the employer to impose a sanction without conducting the investigation.
IMPORTANT The labor code does not designate or standardize a distinct report. What is mandatory is compliance with the research procedure and the requirements of the sanctioning decision.
The role of the reporter in practice
In practice, the report can organize the results of the investigation into an easily trackable internal document. It can support the traceability of the analysis and provide the competent person issuing the decision with a synthesis of the relevant elements.
The report does not replace the summons, the effective administration of evidence, the recording of defenses, or the sanctioning decision. In particular, the mandatory mentions provided by the labor code must be included in the written decision, under penalty of absolute nullity.
Recommended content
In the absence of a mandatory legal model, the content adapts to the procedures and internal regulations. The report must be limited to facts, evidence, and objectively formulated conclusions, without substituting the necessary legal analysis for the decision.
What needs to be checked
· Identification of the employee, the authorized person, and the subject of the investigation.
· Chronological description of the analyzed facts and the relevant internal or contractual norms.
· Record of the summons, presence or absence, and the explanations provided.
· Inventory of the evidence and how it was evaluated.
· Defenses of the employee and their analysis.
· Conclusions of the investigation and, if applicable, the reasoned proposal regarding the continuation of the procedure.
Connection with the sanctioning decision
The sanctioning decision must be issued in writing within 30 calendar days from the acknowledgment of the breach, but no later than 6 months from the commission of the act. It must include a description of the act, the violated norm, the analysis of the defenses, or the reason for not conducting the investigation in case of non-appearance, the legal basis, the term, and the competent court for appeal.
The decision is communicated to the employee within 5 calendar days of issuance and takes effect upon communication. The employee can contest it in the competent courts within 30 calendar days from communication.
IMPORTANT A conclusion from the report does not alone produce the effect of a sanction. The sanction is applied only through the written decision that meets the legal requirements.
Procedure recommendations
· Check the internal regulations, individual contract, and applicable collective contract before starting the investigation.
· Document the summons and effectively grant the opportunity to exercise the right to defense.
· Keep relevant documents and evidence in the internal file, respecting data protection rules.
· Ensure consistency between the report, evidence, and the sanctioning decision.
RELEVANT GESEIDL SERVICES
The Geseidl team can support the review of internal flows and disciplinary research documentation, adapted to the applicable regulations and specific situation.
Geseidl Consulting Group
CECCAR #1 Prahova · CAFR Rating A · ANEVAR · CCF #233 · ISO 9001:2015
Learn more about us →
